What counts as a fault for a mattress
A mattress must be of satisfactory quality: the standard a reasonable person would consider satisfactory given the description, price and circumstances (section 9(2)). Durability, freedom from minor defects and appearance are listed aspects of quality (section 9(3)). Mattress faults tend to sort as follows.
- A permanent dip or body impression. A mattress is meant to support you, so a permanent hollow is a usual-purposes and durability issue (section 9(3)(a) and (e)). Lay a straight edge across the bed, photograph the gap beside a ruler, and date the picture.
- Broken or protruding springs, a loose edge or a torn cover. These can be safety and minor-defect points (section 9(3)(c) and (d)).
- Lumps or foam that has split or crumbled. That is a materials failure, not normal settling, particularly if it appears early.
- The firmness, size or construction is not what the listing said. The main characteristics given by the trader form part of the contract (section 11(4)). A mattress described as a particular size or type that arrives different is a not-as-described claim.
- It does not suit you. Discomfort alone, with nothing wrong with the mattress, is not a fault under the Act. Citizens Advice treats this as changing your mind, which gives you a limited right to return only in some cases (Citizens Advice: return faulty goods). Any trial period a retailer offers is a voluntary promise whose terms you need to read, and we have not verified any retailer's terms.
- A purpose you told the seller about. If before buying you said you needed a mattress for a particular bed frame or a medical need and relied on the seller's advice, section 10 can apply.
What counts as wear and tear or misuse on a mattress
Citizens Advice says you have no legal rights where the item was damaged by wear and tear, an accident or misuse (Citizens Advice: return faulty goods). The Act gives no fixed life for mattresses and we do not quote one. The comparison is with what a reasonable person would expect for the price (section 9(2)(b)).
- Light settling: some softening is expected over time. A dip that shows up early and deepens is different, and your dated photos show the progress.
- Unsuitable base: a seller may say a worn slatted base, slats set too far apart or an unsupported middle caused the dip. Check what base the mattress was sold to be used with and keep a photo of yours.
- Not turning or rotating it: if the care instructions say to turn or rotate and you did not, a seller may use that. Keep the care leaflet and note what you did.
- Stains, liquids and tears: damage you caused is outside your rights. Mattress protectors are not a legal requirement for your Consumer Rights Act rights, in our reading of the Act, but a guarantee may set its own conditions; read it, because guarantees add to your rights rather than replace them (Citizens Advice: claim using a warranty or guarantee).
- Jumping and heavy point loads: broken springs after standing on the bed are a misuse argument. Normal sleeping is what a mattress is sold for.
- Cutting it open or repairing it yourself: GOV.UK says a business need not refund someone who damaged an item trying to repair it, or getting someone else to, though they may still have a right to a repair, replacement or partial refund (GOV.UK: accepting returns and giving refunds).
Practical steps for a mattress claim
- Separate hygiene returns from fault claims. For online or phone orders, the 14-day cancellation rights stop if sealed goods that are not suitable for return for health or hygiene reasons become unsealed after delivery (Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013, regulation 28(3)(a)). GOV.UK gives sealed items that cannot be returned once opened for hygiene reasons, such as underwear, as an example where a business only has to offer a refund if the goods are faulty (GOV.UK: accepting returns and giving refunds). We have not found an official statement on whether mattresses fall into that category, so ask the seller to show its reasoning. A fault claim under the Consumer Rights Act is a different right and is unaffected.
- Check before unsealing if you may want to change your mind. Ask the seller whether it treats the mattress as a hygiene item before you open the packaging. After the 14-day cancellation window has gone, only the fault routes remain.
- Check made-to-measure. Goods made to your specifications or clearly personalised are outside the cancellation right (regulation 28(1)(b)), but fault rights remain.
- Date-stamp evidence around the six-month line. A fault that exists at any time in the six months from delivery is presumed to have existed on delivery (section 19(14)). On the wording of section 19(14), what matters is whether the goods did not conform at any time within the six months, not when you complained, so a photograph dated inside the period is useful evidence even if you write to the seller later.
- Delivery of rolled or boxed mattresses. Goods are at the trader's risk until they come into your physical possession (section 29(2)). If a mattress arrives damaged, tell the seller promptly. Time for the short-term right to reject runs for 30 days from the day after delivery (section 22(3)).
- Disposal of the old mattress is not part of the Act. If the seller's contract promises removal, that is a term of the contract, and a failure to do the service with reasonable care and skill is covered by section 49. Check what the contract said.
- Spare parts. We have not found a regulation we can cite that sets spare-part periods for mattresses, and the Act has no such right.
Worked example: a mattress that starts to sag around month six
This is an invented example to show how the dates work, not a real case. Omar buys a mattress and has it delivered on Monday 6 April 2026.
- The 30-day short-term right to reject ends at the end of Wednesday 6 May 2026 (section 22(3)).
- The presumption that a fault existed on delivery covers the six months beginning with the delivery day, so up to the end of Monday 5 October 2026 (section 19(14)).
- The no-deduction period for a final rejection is counted from the day after delivery and ends at the end of Tuesday 6 October 2026 (section 24(10) and (11)).
Omar first notices the dip and photographs it against a straight edge on 28 September 2026, which is inside the presumption period. He complains to the retailer on 9 October, after the date shown above. The retailer says he is outside six months. Omar answers that the goods did not conform at a time within the six months, shown by his dated photograph, so section 19(14) treats them as not conforming on delivery unless the retailer shows otherwise or shows the presumption is incompatible with how the goods fail (section 19(15)). The retailer offers a replacement mattress. If that also sags, Omar could use the final right to reject, but because that would be after 6 October 2026, a deduction for his use could be made (section 24(8) to (10)). Counting cautiously from purchase, the long-stop is 6 April 2032 in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, or 6 April 2031 in Scotland (GOV.UK).
Frequently asked questions about mattress faults
Can a retailer refuse a mattress fault claim because the mattress was used?
No, not for that reason alone. Use is what a mattress is for. A fault claim under the Consumer Rights Act depends on whether the mattress met the satisfactory-quality standard (section 9). The hygiene exception in the Consumer Contracts Regulations (regulation 28(3)(a)) concerns the 14-day cancellation right for changing your mind, not faults.
The dip is only 2 cm. Is that a fault?
The Act sets no depth. The question is whether, for the price and description, a reasonable person would find the mattress satisfactory (section 9). Some guarantees set their own measurement, and Citizens Advice says guarantees add to your legal rights, so a guarantee threshold does not cap your Act rights. Record the measurement, how it changes, and your base.
I bought a made-to-measure mattress. Can I send it back if I don't like it?
Not under the 14-day cancellation right, which does not apply to goods made to your specifications or clearly personalised (regulation 28(1)(b)). If it has a fault, or is not as ordered, you keep your Consumer Rights Act remedies, and GOV.UK says a business must offer a refund for custom-made items that are faulty.
Does using a mattress protector or turning it affect my rights?
Neither is a condition of the Consumer Rights Act. They may matter to a guarantee, so read its terms, and a seller may argue a stain or lack of rotation caused a fault. Keep the care leaflet and note what you did, so you can show the dip is not down to use.
The short version
| Time since purchase | What you can ask for |
| 0–30 days | Full refund |
| 31 days–6 months | Free repair or replacement, then refund |
| 6 months–6 years (5 in Scotland) | Same, but you show the fault is inherent |
Sources
Check your deadlines: How long do I have to return faulty goods? · Deadline calculator · Faulty after a year?
Other faulty goods
More: The Consumer Rights Act explained · Faulty goods complaint letter · Buying online · Used cars · Digital content