What counts as a fault for a sofa
A sofa must be of satisfactory quality: the standard a reasonable person would consider satisfactory, taking account of the description, the price and the circumstances (section 9(2)). The Act counts appearance and finish, freedom from minor defects, safety and durability among the aspects of quality (section 9(3)). In practice sofa complaints sort like this.
- The frame creaks, twists or a joint fails. A sofa exists to be sat on, so structural failure goes to usual purposes and durability (section 9(3)(a) and (e)). Photograph the break and avoid sitting on it until it is inspected.
- Seat cushions flatten or lose shape quickly; seams split; stitching comes undone. These are appearance, finish and durability points (section 9(3)(b) and (e)). The Act sets no fixed lifespan, so the comparison is with what a reasonable person would expect for the price you paid.
- The colour or fabric does not match the swatch you saw. If you chose from a sample, the goods must match it, and be free from defects that were not apparent on reasonable examination of the sample (section 13). If you chose from a showroom model, they must match the model (section 14).
- The size, recliner mechanism or sofa-bed feature is different from the listing. Main characteristics given by the trader are treated as part of the contract (section 11(4)).
- A smell, a rough finish or visible marks on delivery. Appearance and finish apply from the day of delivery. Raise it immediately and keep photographs.
- Your own fabric or design failed. If you supplied the material, a failure that has its origin in the materials supplied by the consumer is not a failure to conform (section 19(2)), so claims on bespoke sofas upholstered in your own fabric are narrower.
What counts as wear and tear or misuse on a sofa
Citizens Advice says you do not have legal rights if the item was damaged by wear and tear, an accident or misuse (Citizens Advice: return faulty goods). Sofas make this line unusually fuzzy because they are used every day.
- Expected softening: a seat cushion loses some firmness with use, and a seller may say that is wear. The argument against that is timing and price: a reasonable person does not expect a frame or foam to fail within months of purchase, and the price you paid sets expectations (section 9(2)(b)).
- Pilling and fading: light surface pilling is common on some fabrics. Heavy bobbling that appears early, or colour that fades in patches where the sofa was shaded, can be argued as a durability issue.
- Stains and spills: damage you caused is not covered. Stain-protection plans are a separate product sold by the seller or a third party; check what that contract says, which sits alongside your rights.
- Pets, children and heavy loads: a claw tear or a frame snapped by someone standing on an arm is a misuse or accident argument. Normal sitting, including by several people, is the use a sofa is bought for.
- Your own assembly of legs or arms: if you assembled it, the seller may say you caused a loose joint. The installation provision applies only where the trader installs the goods or they are installed under the trader's responsibility (section 15), so a self-assembled item is judged on whether the fault was in the goods themselves.
- Cleaning or repairing it yourself: GOV.UK says a business need not refund a customer who damaged an item by repairing it themselves or getting someone else to, though they may still have a right to repair, replacement or a partial refund (GOV.UK: accepting returns and giving refunds).
Practical steps for a sofa claim
- Know whether it was made to order. If you bought online or by phone, the usual 14-day cancellation right does not apply to goods made to your specifications or clearly personalised (Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013, regulation 28(1)(b)). GOV.UK lists personalised or custom-made items among those where a business only has to offer a refund if the item is faulty (GOV.UK: accepting returns and giving refunds). That removes the change-of-mind route, not your rights for a fault.
- Keep the order paperwork and the swatch. Description, photographs, size and fabric reference are all evidence. Save the order confirmation and any emails about lead times, because the delivery term matters (see the FAQ).
- Inspect at delivery. The goods are at the trader's risk until they come into your physical possession, or that of a person you named (section 29(2)). Open the packaging with the delivery crew, check the finish and note any damage on the paperwork before they leave.
- Photograph the failure the right way. For sagging, lay a straight edge across the seat and photograph the gap. For a frame fault, show the break and its location. Date every photo.
- Ask for repair or replacement first. After the first 30 days, the starting point is a repair or replacement, within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience (section 23(2)). Re-covering or replacing a foam or frame component is a repair; if the same defect returns, you have the price reduction and final right to reject (section 24(5)).
- If the seller has gone under, Citizens Advice's card-payment page explains Section 75 for items above £100 and up to £30,000, and chargeback otherwise (Citizens Advice: getting your money back if you paid by card or PayPal).
- Spare parts. We have not found a regulation we can cite that sets spare-part periods for sofas, and the Consumer Rights Act has no such right.
Worked example: a made-to-order sofa that sags
This is an invented example to show how the dates work, not a real case. Hannah orders a sofa in her chosen fabric on Monday 8 September 2025. It is built to order and delivered on Monday 17 November 2025, so the delivery date, not the order date, starts the clocks.
- Her 30-day short-term right to reject runs to the end of Wednesday 17 December 2025 (section 22(3)).
- The presumption that a fault was there on delivery covers the six months up to the end of Saturday 16 May 2026 (section 19(14)).
- A final rejection exercised up to the end of Sunday 17 May 2026 carries no deduction for use (section 24(10) and (11)).
The seat cushions look flat and the frame creaks, but Hannah only photographs the problem on 12 June 2026. That is after both six-month dates, so she cannot rely on the presumption and has to show the sofa was not of satisfactory quality when delivered. She does this with dated photographs of the gap under a straight edge, the order paperwork showing the price, and a written report from an independent upholsterer who says the foam density and frame joints failed under normal use. She asks for a repair. If it fails, she can reject but a deduction may then be made for her use of the sofa (section 24(8)).
The outer limit is six years in England, Wales and Northern Ireland and five in Scotland (GOV.UK). Counting cautiously from the order date, that is 8 September 2031, or 8 September 2030 in Scotland.
Frequently asked questions about sofa faults
I ordered a made-to-order sofa and changed my mind. Can I cancel?
Probably not. For online or phone orders the 14-day cancellation right does not apply to goods made to your specifications or clearly personalised (Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013, regulation 28(1)(b)). GOV.UK says that for custom-made items a business only has to offer a refund if the item is faulty. A fault, or a sofa that is not as described, still gives you your Consumer Rights Act remedies.
The sofa fabric looks different from the swatch I chose. What are my rights?
If you chose from a sample, the goods must match it, except for differences brought to your attention before the contract was made (section 13). If you chose from a model you saw or examined, section 14 applies instead. If it only differs from the description or listing, that is a not-as-described claim (section 11). Keep the swatch and the order wording.
My sofa was promised in six weeks and has not arrived. What can I do?
If a delivery date or period was agreed and the trader misses it, you can set a reasonable new deadline, and end the contract if that is missed too (section 28(7) and (8)). You can end it straight away if the date was essential, or if the trader refuses to deliver (section 28(6)). Without an agreed time, delivery should be without undue delay and within 30 days of the contract (section 28(3)).
The retailer says sagging after 14 months is normal wear. How do I answer?
The Act sets no lifespan, so the question is what a reasonable person would expect for the price, including durability (section 9(2) and (3)(e)). After six months you may be asked to show the fault was present or developing when you bought it. Dated photos, an independent report and the price you paid are the usual evidence.
The short version
| Time since purchase | What you can ask for |
| 0–30 days | Full refund |
| 31 days–6 months | Free repair or replacement, then refund |
| 6 months–6 years (5 in Scotland) | Same, but you show the fault is inherent |
Sources
- Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 9 (satisfactory quality, durability)
- Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 11 (goods as described)
- Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 13 (goods to match a sample)
- Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 14 (goods to match a model)
- Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 19 (including subsection (2), consumer-supplied materials)
- Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 28 (delivery of goods)
- Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 29 (passing of risk)
- Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013, regulation 28
- GOV.UK: accepting returns and giving refunds
- Citizens Advice: getting your money back if you paid by card or PayPal
- Citizens Advice: return faulty goods
Check your deadlines: How long do I have to return faulty goods? · Deadline calculator · Faulty after a year?
Other faulty goods
More: The Consumer Rights Act explained · Faulty goods complaint letter · Buying online · Used cars · Digital content